I worry I wasn't a good pet owner to my guinea pigs... To the point that I refuse to ever own any pet again, despite never being abusive or neglectful

Charlie1800

New Born Pup
Joined
Oct 8, 2022
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Points
20
Location
Nevada
I had two guinea pigs, the youngest, Ella, died almost a year and a half ago now, while her mom Bella died this January... I did my best to care for them, fed them regularly, gave them plenty of treats, water and vitamins... however I often felt guilty trying to hold them. I got them when they were 3 and 4 respectively, and they were very against being held by me. Every time I'd clean their cage or feed them they'd squeak loudly and run for their hides. If I tried to hold them they'd freak out and try to squirm away, they often bit me, not gently but like "get the heck off me" kind of bites, slightly painful but not mean. When they finally did relax a bit, they just sat their frozen and never relaxed, seemingly terrified, I see people talking about their guinea pigs relaxing and sleeping on their laps and stuff, and that was never even on the horizon for me, all they would do is stare blankly at the wall, wide eyed as they breathed extremely quickly.

Eventually after a year of having them (I had them both almost 3 years, give or take 6 months), I was scared to try holding them anymore, I didn't want to freak them out and give them a heart attack or a stroke as they were older... I still tried, but not nearly as often, maybe once or twice a month. I just felt bad because I felt as if they clearly didn't want me to hold them, and felt insanely guilty for trying because of how they'd react, I tried just letting them hang out on my lap, wrapping them up in blankets (very loosely so they could still move), I tried holding them in slings... Everything I could think of on top of treating them as well as possible... And it never really changed. I talked to them constantly, and if I lightly pet them when they were on top of their hides they would tolerate it for a bit sometimes before freaking out suddenly and running away like I was about to throw them into a wall or eat them. I often wound up crying because I assumed I did something wrong to freak them out, honestly.

My mom (I'm 22, they were a birthday present after a while of asking for pets, 19 when I got them) said I acted like I hated them but I adored them to bits and even still I cry when I think about them and losing them... I know I could've done better but her saying that really makes me feel like I was the worst possible owner for them for not trying more. I feel like I should have just rehomed them since I seemingly treated them so badly.

I feel it's important to include that I have some mental health issues, and while I never neglected their cages, I did eventually let my own fears of upsetting them influence my attempts at getting them to like me... But after a year it truly felt pointless because I'd tried everything, it seemed. We got them from a pet store, and I have no idea about how their previous owners treated them, but at this point I refuse to ever own any pet ever again, let alone prey animals, because if my genuine attempts at trying with them were obviously seen as hateful I just... Don't know how to try any better or harder.
I don't know if I could have done anything differently or tried any harder, and I just need an external third opinion, to be honest.
 
I’m so sorry that happened. From your story it’s definitely sounds like you weren’t a terrible owner. They may have had a terrible owner before you that made them so scared. In the end it sounds like while they might have been frightened, you genuinely gave a safe and loving environment. Which is all one can do. They are lucky to have had someone who cared so much. You may have helped them more than you realised. Some piggies just don’t like to be held. Mine definitely don’t. They’ll occasionally sit on my lap, but on their own terms. They hate to be picked up. And that’s after me having them for their entire lives. I hope you’ll feel better about it, and not be scared to have pets in the future. I have some mental health issues too, and pets have always helped and made me so happy. I wish you the best!
 
I’m sorry you feel this way Charlie1800. I don’t think you were a bad owner. I’m sure you did look after them well. You provided everything a piggy needed. Guinea pigs don’t like being handled because they are prey animals. You respected that. We have to put the welfare of the pigs first. I have two boars that don’t like being picked up but will tolerate a weigh in and health check. They’re 2 and 1/2 yrs old and have always been this way.
So try not to feel that way …your piggies were just being piggies
 
I had seven guinea pigs in a herd and none of them liked being picked up at all. Even the ones that I had got from a rescue as babies.

It is all too easy to beat yourself up. Perhaps try to imagine someone else saying those things and see how you would advise them, I find that I am often far more forgiving of friends than of myself.
 
So sorry to hear that you don't feel like you did a good job. Guinea pigs aren't for everyone. How they were treated before you got them will influence how they would behave with you and it can take a lot of patience and sometimes a very long time for guinea pigs to learn to trust.

Piggies need a confident person who is calm and caring. It's difficult to give them that if you're nervous and the more nervous you are, the more scared the piggies will feel.

Perhaps if you have a rescue near you, you could volunteer to gain some experience and learn how to handle animals. Having someone to show you might help you to gain the confidence you need .

Perhaps even a different species might work better for you such as rats. Rats are loving, intelligent creatures and you can have several of the same sex together. They are easier to handle and will climb onto you rather than you having to pick them up. They do need a very large enclosure with lots of toys and levels to keep them fit and entertained. Rats are great fun to watch and perhaps that would suit you better.

Always think of the environment that an animal is in too as that will affect how the animals feel. Noisy people, shouting, arguing, loud music or TV will cause stress to animals and can make them feel scared. Being near a window can be stressful as piggies will see birds/people outside and as prey animals, that can scare them. Too warm/ too cold, draughts, direct sunlight can all cause stress. There are so many things that can influence how an animal will feel and new animals need time to adjust to a new home and to feel safe.
I hope you can find peace.
We all live and learn x
 
Back
Top