What is this forum's policy?

Pinki

Junior Guinea Pig
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
173
Reaction score
127
Points
305
Location
Bristol
To be honext I find the endless "Take your guinea pig to the vet, do nothing yourself" mantra on this forum is just wrong and makes this forum no longer a useful resource.
Why?
1. Because most vets in the UK will make things worse and have only 2 weeks medical training professionally on "exotics".
2. Because most vets are now owned by insurance companies who also own the insurance policies which is a national scandal.
3. Because most vets are unaffordable to most pet owners now (see point 2).
4. The moderators and presumably owners of this forum are terrified of being sued.

This largely makes this forum of no use anymore. Home treatments by experienced (20 year plus) GP owners are INCREDIBLY USEFUL and often way way more powerful than the useless vets who prescribe Baytril and send you packing, yet are dismissed time and time again by the moderators and the few vets who post here. It's a scandal and ultimately it's the guinea pigs who suffer from this narrow minded 'don't sue me' attitude.

Guinea Lynx is a much more useful resource.

I'm sorry but that's my opinion of what has happened to this forum and I am sure you will delete my post.
 
The law clearly states that nobody other than a qualified vet can diagnose and treat an animal.
Therefore nobody on the forum can tell someone what to do for an issue regardless of how much ownership experience we have - we aren’t vets.
It’s not narrow minded - it’s following the law and for the safety of everyone (animal and human) involved.
It has not just happened to the forum - it has always been illegal to do so and the forum has to comply with the law.
(Even if there are qualified vets on the forum (and at this point I don’t think there is), they still cannot diagnose and treat because they havent been able to have a hands on check of the piggy)

The health and illness section purpose, as clearly stated, is to provide support.
We absolutely do provide lots of practical advice on many aspects, both on posts and in the guides, including caring for sick piggies but it can never form a medical diagnosis or treatment. Home treatments could be detrimental and/or dangerous either by being the wrong thing or by causing delays.
Therefore as it is a legal requirement that qualified vet care and diagnosis is sought, we have to make that clear on every post.
It doesn’t make the forum useless; it makes it law compliant.

Guinea Lynx also clearly states that their forum and advice does not constitute veterinary advice or diagnosis, and that it is the pet owners responsibility to seek qualified vet care.
 
As @Piggies&buns has stated above, the forum stance is in line with UK legal guidelines.
The reality is that by the time a guinea pig shows even the smallest of symptoms, they are probably already very poorly and in desperate need of veterinary attention.
There are several guides which give basic first aid advice for owners whilst they wait for an emergency vet appointment (Emergency and Crisis Care as well as Bridging Care until a Vet Appointment).
I think that vets are amazing, highly qualified people. The ones I have been to (even ones who aren't on the recommended list) have truly gone above and beyond for guinea pig welfare. They have made a positive difference to the welfare of my guinea pigs, even if they don't cure them.
Unfortunately, exotic veterinary medicine in the UK (despite being much more advanced than in many other countries) cannot fix everything. Sometimes, the kindest option is euthanasia, or long-term pain relief before euthanasia. Only a vet can prescribe these sorts of vital medications and euthanise animals.
I am very much of the opinion that you should not take on an animal unless you can pay for their welfare needs, including veterinary costs. Because we don't have a guinea pig NHS in the UK, and most insurance policies aren't suitable, vet bills can quickly cost thousands of pounds for a single guinea pig. Unfortunately, due to society as a whole believing guinea pigs are cheap children's pets, many owners are not aware of this until it is too late. I admire the people on this forum for being open about the time, financial, and emotional impact being a guinea pig owner can have on your life.
The forum is of such great use to those who own or are considering owning guinea pigs. It has had an immensely positive impact on my past guinea pigs' welfare, and I look forward to the guidance it will provide in years to come.
P.S. Regarding your previous thread, please do take @Wiebke 's advice and give the vets a ring. Medication dosage is not something to be messed around with.
 
Hi @Pinki. Thank you for posting your views. I do actually agree with you that a lot of vets are useless when it comes to treating guinea pigs (obviously not all). But that being said it’s up to us piggy owners to find a qualified vet with lots of experience with piggies.

Also unfortunately piggies are not cheap pets and vet bills are something to be considered when acquiring a new pet. I wouldn’t home treat my dog so why would I try to home treat my piggy?

I believe this forum is an amazing place to offer support to piggy parents who are going through any issues with their piggies.

Sometimes the hardest issues they are facing is with the sheer exhaustion and anxiety of caring for their sick piggy (I’ve been there). They need to hear that they are doing great and to keep going. This is the time that people’s own experiences are invaluable. And if the worst comes to the worst then they need to hear they did their best.

I’m sure your post will not be deleted as we appreciate the discussion it has started.
 
I would’ve gotten nowhere without the support, knowledge and advice of vets.

I find the mindset that guinea pigs can be healed, treated and diagnosed at home to be quite naive and entitled.

Vets are pricy, be it exotic vets or otherwise. The financial losses is what a responsible owner considers before getting pets.



Your post comes off as very ugly; it’s easy to be rude when anonymous, I wonder if that’s how you truly want to be. Aim to start discussions without the goal of “one-upping” or hurting someone, I assure you the discussions will be much more beneficial.
 
Without baytril my guinea pig would be dead. A very painful death. Without X-rays I wouldn't know he had CBS. Without daily meds he might suffer. I have a special needs pig and yes he is expensive, but no animals are going to suffer under my watch.
 
I'm guessing OP doesn't have a means of finding a qualified guinea pig vet (?). I mean many of us here travel far and wide just to get seen by vets that are very knowledgeable with guinea pigs. But you can't generalise that vets are just there to grab your money as they please. Vets are one of the highest suicide professions according to stats. They are more than qualified to diagnose pets illnesses than someone who never studied veterinary medicine, albeit not all really have guinea pig knowledge.

I mean OP, would you rather anyone just tell you to not seek a doctor if you are ill and just continue to get home remedy all the time. I'm sure if you have continuous cough and cold, or is bleeding somewhere for quite some time, you would rather know the reason why than guess what's wrong with you and just patch it everything with plasters. You are lucky you are in the UK because we get free healthcare (well paid by tax). And vet fees here are I think probably cheaper than in the US, based on some people that posts about it. They also don't have much vets there that guinea pig savy.
 
Agree about the lack of piggie savy vets and the cost of the vets but this should all be factored in BEFORE getting a pigs not after.

I have found the support of people on here invaluable over the past few years, not only from a knowledge perspective but from a "don't have a mental breakdown" perspective.

Plus if you have 20+ years worth of experience and know your stuff surely you don't need to be looking for advice on here.
 
If it helps, having had a look at your last post. You can call any vet to have a dose double checked for free..

I am one of the quite "old school" people when it comes to doing things at home, and I can do quite a bit. My vet has taught me how to do subQ injections and incisor burring at home, for example. And even then, with having special needs animals I am at the vet on an almost weekly basis. There are a lot of things that cannot (and in most cases definitely shouldnt) be explained over the internet.

There is absolutely no way that even the best exotics vet can, for example, tell you over the internet whether bloody urine is cystitis, UTI, tumour, blood clot, a stone or a ruptured bladder. Same goes for almost any ailment a guinea pig may pick up, and trying to explain how to palpate or express a bladder online would likely result in the death of the animal, much to the probable devestation of the owner.

The best that can and should be offered online is first aid to keep an animal comfortable until they see a vet, reassurance, advice on what to expect or ask for while at the vet etc. Offering a diagnosis and dosing prescription medication is illegal. And no one should be risking legal action for a voluntary position. If you need veterinary help, a veterinary professional should be sought and paid for, otherwise surrendering the animal to somewhere or someone else is a valid option if vet bills are too expensive. But the forum, or any online resource shouldn't be replacing a vet.
 
I only discovered the wonderful world of guinea pigs two years ago. As an inexperienced owner I have found myself in the unfortunate position of having a satin and bladder prone pigs. As soon as I had them I accepted the duty of care to ensure getting them to the vet whenever necessary. If not for the supportive people that are the core and heart of this forum I would spend far too much time hovering over my boys. Annoying them as well as being unable to relax and enjoy them. Especially my satin, it's because of @Eriathwen and her knowledge that I don't spend every day looking for signs of GPSS as I now know that at his age if he does have it it's mild. Being able to discuss and read about others experiences does assuage my anxiety somewhat.
The support, kindness and empathy on this forum is priceless, especially in these modern times when far too many use the anonymity of the Internet to demonstrate their worst tendencies by being cruel.
Also I can drone on about my fabulous boys and drool over pictures of all the other gorgeous piggies.
 
I wonder why you entitled your thread “What is this Forum’s policy?” You quite clearly know our policy and just want to vent your spleen about it. I’m not going to repeat everything that’s been said above. The policy has been very clearly explained and the forum has been an invaluable resource to countless owners, whilst remaining on the right side of the law. We are all volunteers giving our time for free. If you no longer value our support and advice you are course free to ignore it and do whatever you wish. Bad mouthing us and our policies, however, wins little sympathy and you may find a lack of support in future if members no longer wish to respond to your threads.
 
There have been a number of things thrown into the ring in this thread, which I would like to put into a bit more of a perspective since the discussion has arisen because of some personal perspectives, which are quite obviously clashing invidually with what this forum is about, the medical situation and the recent massive hike in vet fees.


1) The forum pre-dates social media, is not part of them and is officially classed as a public online space, subject to UK laws and regulations (the same as US based Guinea Lynx forum for their own country, which has a very similar disclaimer to ours). We have to work within in this legal framework. It is very explicit and totally unequivocal when it comes to seeking veterinary care in the UK.
Unfortunately, UK online restrictions and controls are about to tighten even further in just a few weeks. The forum can be closed down anytime if we are found in open breach of regulations.


2) This is the reason why our forum is not a self-help forum but one that supports owners when to seek vet care, making the best of it and supporting their piggies' care at home - we basically try to cover all the care and recovery areas that vets can't.

However, remote access can never replace any hands-on examination and any additional diagnostics; we have to be aware of our limitations at all time and have to tread a very careful balance.
I can assure you that as a long term member and/or mod over time you actually learn from your own mistakes, including where better not to openly guess or where to be extremely careful. What may seem arbitrary to you usually has a very good and often rather painful experience and reason behind it.

What this forum does explicitly not provide is DIY treatment on spec at home. If you are looking for a place that does, then we are quite simply not it. This is where your own expectations and frustrated need seem to clash with our forum policy.

We can push the boat out as far as providing practical first aid, bridging and acute crisis emergency advice, which will also be there for members in other countries who do have extremely limited vet care and medical access or for any under-age forum readers who are not yet allowed to join.


3) When you are choosing guinea pigs or other any other small rodents as pets you have to be aware that they are classed as exotic pets because - unlike rabbits - they have never been a farm animal (i.e. been kept traditionally either for farm work or been raised as a food source). This historic categorisation is unfortunately not going to be changed anytime soon.

Unfortunately, this means that piggies do not feature large on any general vet's curriculum. As exotics, they are sadly still often seen as a common children's pet although with more and more women becoming vets, the tide has started to turn and there is now more interest, not least because there is a larger field to play on. However, in terms of research, guinea pigs still lag badly behind although there is more of it going on now but we are basically decades behind other common pet species.

We have a member recommended vets list on the top bar to help you find as good a vet as possible. What we quite simply cannot do is check over 6000 registed UK clinics and literally tens of thousands of vets with both a high mobility and drop out rate so our list has by its very nature to be very spotty and we rely on member feedback for updates. But it is at least something.

Urban non-exotics small pets clinics often have somebody who can cover small exotics pets but not all and not necessarily on all days.

UK vets also have access to a medications resource which states for every species the safe bandwidth within a medication can be prescribed, potential side effects and dangerous interactions with other meds in order to minimise the risk of medical fatalities - which on the whole is actually working.
What it cannot prevent is potential plain reading or typing mistakes - if you have concerns over a dosage, it is your full right as a customer to call the clinic to confirm with the vet or to ask your vet politely for their thoughts behind the prescription.

However, with officially licensed medication for guinea pigs still extremely limited, vets - if they can, and not all are allowed to - need to transfer from other species. Usually you may need to see an exotics vet for more than the basic meds, and unfortunately it won't cheap.


4) Vets and cost
There are different levels of cost and vet care that are provided in various clinics - they range from charity for benefit claimants to no frills clinics (often in conjunction with a pet shop chain), to general small pet clinics to full exotics and super-vet hospitals. You get the level of service you pay for. General vets seeing guinea pigs on a fairly regular basis often swot up on small rodents in their free time; those that rarely see them won't have the same need.

It should also be taken into consideration that many owners will sadly not see a vet with an ill guinea pig, which then also translates into less incentive and familiarity for more vets. This problem actually works both ways.

Sadly, with the massive hike in medication cost, fees have sky rocketed in recent years and all pet owners are currently feeling the pinch. What most owners are not aware of is that the highest budget post in running a clinic is generally the uneconomic stock of very small medication amounts at the clinic, not to mention the recent massive rise in electricity bills and most certainly not the salaries of nurses and most vets.

This has resulted in the rise of veterinary chains and groups, and the near total loss of independent clinics; most of them have sold out to a group by now (which is able to bulk order medications for instance and can provide other synergies, including in some groups an exotics vet on tap). The extra gains money made from such groups with over-hiked fees is however going to any owners of such chains; not further down.

There is also a worldwide over-demand for medication and some of them can be very hard to get hold of for vets due to human demand (like for instance ranitidine for acute bloating; the veterinary UK brand used be called zantac.)


5) Diagnostics
The one area where there has been a recent true expansion of knowledge is diagnostics, which are sadly very costly. Unfortunately, they often do not necessarily result in easier and better treatment but more in finding new or more difficult to treat issues.
Any new medication needs time for testing to see whether they are working for guinea pigs, too. The more we expand the horizon, the more truly tricky problems seem to be coming up. But this is all a very slow, cumbersome and rather patchy or haphazard process.


6) Are you aware that vets/veterinary nurses are the profession with the highest suicide rate?
Vets and nurses choose their profession because they usually deeply care. They work long hours in a demanding profession where they are often unable to cure and are at all times fully exposed to the high emotional involvement of their owners. The drop out rate is massive; new vets last often just a very few years.


7) Questioning our own commitment
Personally - having to face similar long term challenges with finding the right balance between offering emotional support but needing to protect myself from the constant risk of sympathy and emotional burnout - my own respect for any vet is very high. They are all trying their very best under often taxing circumstances.

I admit to having a red flag issue with people who categorically call all vets 'useless'. Too many local general vets have saved piggies of mine over the decades after all; not rarely going beyond. But then I have an issue with generalisations anyway, especially negative ones because things are usually never as straightforward as they are made out.

Please respect that we are running a friendly and supportive free of charge no-profit community group for adults from all over the world that is entirely financed by voluntary member donations.
All staff are generously giving their own free time for free, including a lot of emotional and mental involvement in order to support quite literally tens of thousands of piggies and - uniquely for any guinea pig group - their owners as well during some very stressful and difficult times. As do our forum regulars; all of us in our own way and to our own best ability.

We have put a lot of effort into creating a safe and friendly space for often very vulnerable people and are proud of the special place we have achieved. Just because it is not what you are specifically looking for, what we have on this forum is currently way out there compared to any other group. We are decidely not a place looking to cater for the widest range of owners looking for a quick answer or the cheapest possible option but for those who appreciate the ongoing and personalised community support we offer. We are deliberately concentrating on a specific segment of the piggy group market, making the most of our indepence from social media.


PS: If you have any concerns about a specific medication, then taking it up with the vet and the clinic is the best place because we - like you - are not part to their diagnostic findings and thought processes and can at the best only make a rather haphazard educated guess. None of us on here has got the relevant training, which actually makes a surprisingly large part of any vet's curriculum. Going by our own experience only works if we have actually come across a comparable case, which you can never count on.
And yes, just like with everybody, mistakes can happen. Decimal mistakes are not all that uncommon. The problem is that we cannot necessarily spot them easily depending on the allowed bandwidth of prescription and the specific purpose.

 
To be honext I find the endless "Take your guinea pig to the vet, do nothing yourself" mantra on this forum is just wrong and makes this forum no longer a useful resource.
Why?
1. Because most vets in the UK will make things worse and have only 2 weeks medical training professionally on "exotics".
2. Because most vets are now owned by insurance companies who also own the insurance policies which is a national scandal.
3. Because most vets are unaffordable to most pet owners now (see point 2).
4. The moderators and presumably owners of this forum are terrified of being sued.

This largely makes this forum of no use anymore. Home treatments by experienced (20 year plus) GP owners are INCREDIBLY USEFUL and often way way more powerful than the useless vets who prescribe Baytril and send you packing, yet are dismissed time and time again by the moderators and the few vets who post here. It's a scandal and ultimately it's the guinea pigs who suffer from this narrow minded 'don't sue me' attitude.

Guinea Lynx is a much more useful resource.

I'm sorry but that's my opinion of what has happened to this forum and I am sure you will delete my post.
You've had some very good responses on here.I've had my share of bad vets but I would never try and home treat.This forum is invaluable.We get support and sometimes people giving their own personal experiences for different situations which really helps when you've got a poorly piggy.It sounds like you need to find a good guinea pig vet,you shouldn't be saying the forum is no longer a useful resource.
 
Over the years I have kept guinea pigs I feel I have been very fortunate in having access to excellent vet care.
The vets may not have been exotic specialists but have been willing to do the research required when faced with a guinea pig.
They have been incredibly caring if a piggy has died in surgery, had to be pts.
On only one occasion have I been referred to a specialist exotic clinic.
Yes - fees are high so it makes sense to set up a vet fund for when it may be be necessary.
Yes - get a second opinion if you’re not happy with your vet’s advice.
Generally, over the years, vet care for guinea pigs has improved significantly.

This is the place we share personal experience but can’t advise outside UK law.
I, for one, would hate to lose the forum because we fail to operate within the law.
 
To be honext I find the endless "Take your guinea pig to the vet, do nothing yourself" mantra on this forum is just wrong and makes this forum no longer a useful resource.
Why?
1. Because most vets in the UK will make things worse and have only 2 weeks medical training professionally on "exotics".
2. Because most vets are now owned by insurance companies who also own the insurance policies which is a national scandal.
3. Because most vets are unaffordable to most pet owners now (see point 2).
4. The moderators and presumably owners of this forum are terrified of being sued.

This largely makes this forum of no use anymore. Home treatments by experienced (20 year plus) GP owners are INCREDIBLY USEFUL and often way way more powerful than the useless vets who prescribe Baytril and send you packing, yet are dismissed time and time again by the moderators and the few vets who post here. It's a scandal and ultimately it's the guinea pigs who suffer from this narrow minded 'don't sue me' attitude.

Guinea Lynx is a much more useful resource.

I'm sorry but that's my opinion of what has happened to this forum and I am sure you will delete my post.
If you enjoy guinea lynx more, there's your answer, it's been nice knowing you. 👍
 
I remember seeing someone posting on here about wanting a home remedy for a guinea pig that had broken their legs after being dropped and refusing to go to a vet. A BROKEN LEG. How irresponsible would it be to suggest anything other than emergency first aid and to do the right thing and go to the vet?!

I've seen the Facebook groups with a free-for-all policy and used them once myself in desperation when one of mine had a mystery wound that wouldn't heal, defying both the collective knowledge of this Forum and that of local exotic specialists who went out of their way to consult other clinics and literature. Quite frankly, some of the suggestions in that group were downright dangerous, and that's when the commenters bothered to read the post in full.

If that's what you're after, then perhaps this isn't the place for you - though you'll always receive the best informed and most responsible advice if you need it.
 
This Forum is a wonderful resource of information and over the years has saved at least one of my guinea pigs life who had dental issues. You are an owner and have a duty of care. If your pet is sick then the only person who is legally allowed to treat that animal is a qualified vet. The cost of veterinary care has gone up, it’s a cost we all have to carry, I find a regular payment into a savings account helps. You are correct that two major financial organisations are taking over many independent vet practices but that is absolutely no reason for you to slag off the Guinea Pig Forum and all the incredible work and effort the staff put in free of charge to help owners and their guinea pigs

Your time would be better off finding a really good and experience guinea pig vet in your local area (or be prepared to travel a longer distance), well worth the effort
 
Last edited:
Back
Top