I think that the bedspreads are much better looking, but I would try to make them yourself, or get someone you know who is good at those kinds of things to help. All it is is a fitted fleece over an absorbant layer. You could put towels or incontinence pads or puppy pads etc underneath. If you don't want to make them, then I would say go with fleece - It will be the same, just not fitted, as you will still need an absorbant layer to go underneath.